The aesthetic criterion application for analysis of the of telecommunication systems evolution scenarios

N.A. Sokolov

Abstract


It is proposed to introduce the aesthetic criterion called "the degree of technical excellence" in the list of indicators that are used in the analysis of various scenarios for the telecommunication system development. A similar criterion commonly referred to as the "principle of beauty" has long been used in scientific research. The criterion "degree of technical excellence" does not depend on the specific reason of the analysed stage of the telecommunication system evolution. It includes three components: nontriviality, fundamentality, and performance. First component is directly related to innovative solutions. Second component determines the duration of the existence of a concept that is capable of evolution with regard to changing requirements. Third component in the simplest case is efficiency. All components can be estimated numerically using the method of expert estimates. The article proposes a simple method for the numerical characterization of the degree of technical excellence. Attention is focused on the characteristic features of the component "Efficiency". Two examples concerning the packet technologies are considered. It is shown that opposite conclusions can be obtained on the level of efficiency depending on the formulation of the problem being solved.


Full Text:

PDF (Russian)

References


Migdal A.B. Poiski istiny. – M.: Molodaja gvardija, 1983, 239 s.

Migdal A.B. O krasote nauki. – Nauka i zhizn', 1983, #3, s. 59-65.

Kotina S.V. Problemnaja situacija i princip krasoty v nauke. Avtoreferat dissertacii na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni doktora filosofskih nauk. – M.: Rossijskaja Akademija nauk. NII kul'tury, 1992, 55 s.

Ovsjannikov A.A. Obshhestvo potreblenija v Rossii: sistemnost' i total'nost' krizisa. – Vestnik MGIMO, 2010, # 3, s. 222-234.

Bralla J.G. Design for Excellence. – New York: McGraw-Hill, 1996, 326p.

Gill P.S. Standards and Technical Excellence. – Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management, 2014, Vol. 6, # 2, pp. 109-110.

Sokolov N.A. Zadachi planirovanija setej jelektrosvjazi. – SPb.: Tehnika svjazi, 2012, 432 s.

Mamardashvili M.K. Jestetika myshlenija. – M.: Moskovskaja shkola politicheskih issledovanij, 2000, 416 s.

Gol'dshtejn B.S. Sistemy kommutacii. – SPb.: BHV, 2003, 318 s.

Gol'dshtejn B.S., Sokolov N.A. Ob odnom puti rekonstrukcii GTS. – Vestnik svjazi, 2011, #4, s. 58-60.

Afanas'ev V.V., Gornostaev Ju.M. Jevoljucija mobil'nyh setej. – M.: MCNTI, 2001, 139 s.

David, K., Berndt H. 6G vision and requirements: Is there any need for beyond 5G? – IEEE Vehicular Technology Magazine, 2018, #13, pp. 72-80.

Orlov A.I. Organizacionno-jekonomicheskoe modelirovanie. Chast' 2. Jekspertnye ocenki. – M.: MGTU im. N.Je. Baumana, 2011, 488 s.

Ostrejkovskij V.A. Teorija nadezhnosti. – M.: Vysshaja shkola, 2008, 464 s.

Shirjaev V.I., Shirjaev E.V. Prinjatie reshenij: Prognozirovanie v global'nyh sistemah. – M.: URSS, 2013, 176 s.

Olifer V., Olifer N. Komp'juternye seti. Principy, tehnologii, protokoly. – SPb.: Piter, 2017, 992 s.

Bellami D.K. Cifrovaja telefonija. – M.: Jeko-Trendz, 2004, 640 s.

Vasil'chenko A.I., Denis'eva O.M., Zharkov M.A., Stojanov M.N., Urm Je.Je., Junakov P.A. Sistema telefonnoj signalizacii po obshhemu kanalu (sistema OKS). M.: Svjaz', 1980, 136 s.

Kozhanov Ju.F. Interfejsy i protokoly setej sledujushhego pokolenija. – SPb.: Al'faret, 2006, 218 s.

Modarressi A.R., Mohan S. Control and Management in Next Generation Networks: Challenges and Opportunities. – IEEE Communications Magazine, 2000, Vol. 38, # 10, pp. 94-102.

Sokolov N.A. Processy konvergencii, integracii i konsolidacii v sovremennoj telekommunikacionnoj sisteme. – Connect! Mir svjazi, 2007, #10, s. 78-82.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Abava  Absolutech Fruct 2020

ISSN: 2307-8162